I’m writing a horror short story with a fantasy background. It has a problem. Here are the opening two paragraphs:
Fair proud a lad I was, and bold, so when the healer sent me to look for the royal’s berry, “Crimson the fruit, and set upon a throne of three leaves, no more and no less, green shot through with purple, like unto the robes of our fair Duke, who holds the throne in waiting ever” — I rode much farther than wise down the Nixie Path. Legend had it that if night fell while you were on this way, then you would ride into the Hidden End, never to return. Bold indeed I was, and a fool beside, so I spurred my pony into the hanging vines and narrow reaches of that path.
The way was gloomy but the air still fresh, as ever it was where the Hidden People live, so once an hour as close as I could judge I would dismount and bow to each corner of the rose in reverence. “Spirits of the Forest, East, West, South, and North, bear the passage of my humble pony and myself. I come not to harm any creature but in search of your gift, as our people have for these many years.” So it was I believe that no harm was done to me and had I no fell vision until the fifth hour of my search. I was off my pony and pulling aside the bracken, seeing any herb but the berry I sought, when a trail of purple-veined leaves caught my eye.
Well, not horrible, but not horror-evoking either. Later on, the magic begins to work but let’s get it going early instead. How? By creating a bit of history that’s more explicit. A reaction by our naive, cocky protagonist would help, as well. So let’s think up a bit of work and a hapless victim as foreshadowing. A name, we need a name, a name with Shakespearean flavor. Bung should do. The name of someone a bit blockheaded, someone who is about to make a final, fatal mistake in our fairy path, the Nixie Path. We’re talking about fairies as the monstrous, mischievous, horrible little critters they used to be known before sentimental writers and Walt Disney got ahold of them.
How about…
Put that right between the two paragraphs. The healer’s apprentice, fearfully remembers a tale of how the local magical beings deliver a lesson to old Bung. That should bring the horror right to the front.